Comparison to Other Approaches

The lack of built-in string manipulation in Fortran has led to several different solutions over the years. This page compares StringiFor to the three main alternatives identified by Clive Page [1].

The Four Approaches

1. Standard character type

Fixed-length at compile time. Simple and universally supported, but severely limited:

character(len=3) :: s
s = 'abcdefgh'   ! silently truncated to 'abc'

2. Deferred-length allocatable character

Introduced in Fortran 2003. Removes the fixed-length constraint but array elements must still all have the same length:

character(len=:), allocatable :: s
character(len=:), allocatable :: arr(:)

s = 'Hello '
s = s // 'World'    ! no trim() needed, length adapts

allocate(character(len=99) :: arr(10))  ! all 10 elements are len=99

3. aniso_varying_string (Ian Harvey's ISO implementation)

A derived type wrapping a deferred-length allocatable character, implementing ISO/IEC 1539-2:2000. Solves the array-element problem but has I/O and slicing limitations:

type(varying_string), allocatable :: arr(:)
allocate(arr(10))   ! elements can have different lengths

4. StringiFor

Shares the same philosophy as aniso_varying_string — a derived type wrapping a single character(kind=CK, len=:), allocatable member — but adds an extensive OOP API modelled after Python's string methods.

type(string), allocatable :: arr(:)
allocate(arr(10))   ! elements can have different lengths

Issue-by-Issue Comparison

Issue	character	Deferred-length	aniso_varying_string	StringiFor
Fixed length at compile time	✗	✓	✓	✓
Silent truncation on assignment	✗	✓	✓	✓
trim()-cluttered code	✗	✓	✓	✓
Significant trailing spaces	✗	✓	✓	✓
Single definition syntax	✗	✗	✓	✓
Array allocation (variable lengths)	✗	✗	✓	✓
Array initialization	✗	✗	✓	✓
I/O support	✓	✓	~	~
Substring (slice) notation	✓	✓	~	~
Fortran intrinsics as-is	✓	✓	~	~

✓ = good support · ~ = partial support · ✗ = bad or no support

Notes on partial I/O support

Both aniso_varying_string and StringiFor support I/O through defined I/O type-bound procedures (read(formatted), write(formatted), etc.). The DT edit descriptor (defined I/O) is fully supported in gfortran ≥ 7.1. For simpler portability, the //'' concatenation idiom converts a string to a character on the fly:

print "(A)", my_string//''

Notes on slice notation

Standard slice notation (s(2:5)) cannot be applied to a derived type. StringiFor provides the slice method and the chars([first][, last]) method as equivalents:

! Standard character
print "(A)", s(2:5)

! StringiFor equivalents
print "(A)", my_string%slice(first=2, last=5)//''
print "(A)", my_string%chars(2, 5)

StringiFor's Distinctive Features

Beyond solving the same issues as aniso_varying_string, StringiFor adds:

• Number casting — assign any PENF integer or real directly to a string; cast back with to_number(kind=...)
• File I/O — read_file, write_file, read_line for common file-handling patterns
• Path manipulation — basedir, basename, extension
• Case conversion — camelcase, snakecase, startcase, capitalize, swapcase
• Encoding — Base64 encode/decode via BeFoR64
• Color output — ANSI terminal colorization via FACE
• Glob — file-system pattern matching
• Namespace safety — all functionality is accessible through the single string type; no global namespace pollution unless the overloaded intrinsic interfaces are explicitly imported

References

[1] Clive Page, Improved String-handling in Fortran, October 2015.

[2] Ian Harvey, aniso_varying_string, 2016.